How Repeat Guests Become Your Cabin's Best Bookings
Psst... We've Got a Secret THANKSGIVING Deal! CLICK TO BOOK!

How Repeat Guests Become Your Cabin’s Best Bookings

HomeHow Repeat Guests Become Your Cabin’s Best BookingsHow Repeat Guests Become Your Cabin’s Best Bookings

For Big Bear Cabin Owners

How 200,000 Past Guests Become Your Cabin’s Most Profitable Bookings

A guest who has already stayed with us doesn’t need a platform to find us again. That changes what the booking is worth to you.

Every vacation rental booking has an acquisition cost. On a marketplace, it’s the commission. With repeat guests, it’s close to nothing. Over three decades of hosting travelers in Big Bear, we’ve built a database of more than 200,000 past guests, and each season they’re invited back by email to book directly with us. For a cabin owner, that list is demand you don’t have to rent from anyone.

Family carrying bags up the front steps of the Big Bear cabin they have stayed in before
Guests who return to Big Bear year after year are the foundation of direct bookings.

Rented Demand vs. Owned Demand

There are two ways a guest finds your cabin.

Rented demand comes from marketplaces such as Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com. They spend heavily to attract travelers, show your cabin among thousands of others, and charge a fee on each booking. The platform keeps the guest relationship, and when that guest plans another trip, they return to the platform and may choose a different cabin.

Owned demand comes from people who already know the company: past guests, email subscribers, and travelers who come to the website directly. No marketplace stands in the middle, and no marketplace collects a commission.

Marketplaces are valuable and every cabin should be on them. But a rental that depends on them entirely is paying to reacquire its customers again and again. A past-guest list is how a management company stops paying twice for the same traveler.

Why Repeat Guests Net More

Repeat and direct bookings are worth more to an owner for four reasons.

1. No platform commission

Host-side fees on the major platforms run from roughly 8% to more than 15% of a booking. A returning guest who books on BigBearVacations.com carries none of that. We compare the fees side by side in how Big Bear Vacations drives more revenue for your cabin.

2. Longer stays, booked earlier

Lodgify’s 2026 State of the Industry Report, which analyzed more than 1.6 million bookings, found that direct bookings in 2025 produced stays 45.2% longer and booking windows 51.3% longer than OTA bookings, at slightly higher average daily rates. Longer stays mean fewer turnovers for the same revenue. Earlier bookings mean a calendar that fills with less last-minute discounting.

3. Guests who know what to expect

Someone who has stayed in Big Bear before knows the drive, the weather, and what a mountain cabin is like in January. They can choose a home that fits their group and arrive prepared for mountain conditions. Familiar guests are easier guests.

4. Reviews and referrals

Returning guests are returning because the last stay went well. Satisfied guests leave strong reviews and tell friends, which feeds the next round of bookings. We look at that loop in why reputation matters for your cabin.

How a Past-Guest List Turns Into Bookings

A list of 200,000 names is only an asset if it’s used well. Guest lifecycle marketing is the practice of staying in touch with travelers before, during, and after a stay so that the next trip starts with you.

The cycle looks like this:

  1. A guest books and stays. However they first found the cabin, they now have a relationship with the company that hosted them.
  2. The stay goes well. Clean home, fast answers, no surprises. Nothing in marketing works without this step.
  3. The guest hears from us again. Past guests are invited back by email each season, with a reason to return and a simple way to book direct.
  4. The next booking skips the marketplace. The guest goes straight to the website, and the owner keeps more of the stay.

The first booking may well come from Airbnb or Vrbo. That’s fine. The aim is for the second, third, and fourth to come direct.

Guest reading a Big Bear cabin getaway email on her phone beside a fireplace with snowy pines outside the window
A well-timed email to a past guest can fill nights that a marketplace would charge a commission on.

The Campaign Calendar

Email to past guests isn’t one newsletter. Different sends do different jobs, and each one maps to a specific gap in a cabin’s calendar. The table shows the main types of campaign a past-guest list makes possible.

Past-guest email campaigns and the bookings they produce
Campaign typeWhen it goes outWho receives itThe gap it fills
Season openerAhead of ski season and ahead of summerGuests who stayed in that season beforeEarly bookings for peak dates, placed before the rush
Repeat-stay invitationAround the anniversary of a past tripGuests whose last stay was about a year agoAnnual traditions that rebook the same week
Holiday and event sendBefore Thanksgiving, Christmas, Presidents’ Week, the Fourth of July, and OktoberfestThe full list, or guests who favor that holidayHigh-value holiday stays booked direct
Shoulder-season offerSpring and fallFlexible travelers, couples, and midweek guestsQuiet weeks in April, May, and October
Gap-night offerA week or two before open datesGuests within driving distance who can travel on short noticeOrphaned nights between two reservations
Snow alertWhen a storm is on the way or fresh snow has fallenWinter guestsLast-minute winter weekends

Two of these deserve a closer look.

Gap-night offers solve a problem owners rarely see. When one guest checks out Thursday and the next arrives Saturday, the night in between is too short for most travelers to find by searching. A targeted message to past guests who live a short drive away can sell it. Because Big Bear’s guests come largely from Southern California, there’s a deep pool of people able to say yes on a few days’ notice.

Shoulder-season offers go to the guests most likely to travel when it’s quiet. Filling those weeks with returning guests who book direct is far better than slashing rates on a marketplace and paying commission on the discount.

What One Owner Can’t Build Alone

An individual owner can collect emails from past guests, and should. The limits show up quickly.

  • Scale. One cabin hosts a limited number of groups a year. It would take lifetimes to reach a list of 200,000. A new cabin in our program is introduced to that audience immediately.
  • Platform restrictions. Marketplaces limit the guest contact details they share with hosts. A manager with its own booking site and reservations team collects that information directly.
  • Choice. A past guest of one cabin can only rebook that cabin. If their group grows, their dates are taken, or they want to be closer to the lake this time, a single owner loses them. A manager with many homes keeps them, and your cabin benefits from guests who first stayed somewhere else in the portfolio.
  • Time and tools. Segmenting a list, timing sends, and measuring results is a job in itself.

That third point works in your favor from the start. A guest who loved a two-bedroom near the Village five years ago and now needs room for three families is a ready-made booking for a larger home. Your cabin inherits thirty years of relationships it had no part in building.

Email is one piece of a wider system that also includes search marketing, paid search, social media, and a reservations team. You can see how the parts fit on our revenue page. Pricing ties into it as well, because a direct booking changes what a given rate nets the owner, as covered in how Big Bear Vacations prices your cabin.

The Guest You Already Have

Most rental marketing is about finding the next stranger. The better opportunity is usually the guest who already came, had a good time, and would come again if someone asked. That guest costs almost nothing to reach, stays longer, books earlier, and leaves more of the rate in the owner’s pocket.

A marketplace will always sell you access to travelers. A past-guest list means a growing share of your bookings never has to be bought at all.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are repeat guests more profitable than new guests?

Repeat guests typically book direct, so there is no marketplace commission on the stay. Industry data also shows direct bookings run longer and are made further ahead than OTA bookings. Lower acquisition cost, fewer turnovers, and earlier bookings all raise what the owner nets.

How many past guests does Big Bear Vacations market to?

Big Bear Vacations has a database of more than 200,000 past guests, built over three decades of hosting travelers in Big Bear. Those guests are invited back by email each season and can book directly on BigBearVacations.com.

Will past guests of other cabins book my cabin?

Yes. Returning guests often choose a different home on their next trip because their group size, dates, or preferred location has changed. A cabin that joins a larger portfolio is shown to guests who first stayed in other homes, which is a source of demand a single owner can’t create.

What is a gap-night offer?

A gap-night offer promotes one or two open nights that sit between existing reservations. These short gaps are hard to sell through normal search because most travelers look for longer stays. Emailing nearby past guests with a timely offer can fill nights that would otherwise go empty.

Can I build my own guest email list as a self-managing owner?

You can, and it’s worth doing, but it grows slowly. One cabin hosts only so many groups a year, and marketplaces limit the guest contact details they pass along. A list large enough to move a calendar takes many homes and many years to build.

Do direct bookings replace Airbnb and Vrbo?

No. Marketplaces remain important for reaching travelers who have never stayed in Big Bear. Direct and repeat bookings work alongside them, lowering the average cost of filling the calendar and reducing dependence on any one platform.

Recommended Properties